Affeldt bought dough from the supermarket and put Bumgarner to work in the kitchen. He told Bumgarner, “You! You make me cookies. You’re staying in this house, free rent.”

“I made him put on this apron, and he made cookies. We got pictures. Ally was sitting there. We enjoyed it.”

Bumgarner remembers it differently, saying Affeldt made the cookies, forced Bumgarner to remove them from the oven then snapped the photo.”